Which is the best revision of the student’s claim that …

English Questions

Which is the best revision of the student’s claim that serves as a rebuttal to the counterclaim? A. Just like soccer and baseball, golf is a competitive game even at a social level, and this meets the definition of a sport. B. Many activities require skill, such as chess, gardening, and computer programming, yet none are considered sports. C. Some believe golf is a game of luck‚ÄöAieven professional golfers have stated this‚ÄöAibut if that were true, every lucky golfer would be a pro. D. Golf is an excellent form of exercise, with the average golfer burning over 700 calories during a nine-hole round, and it requires strength and flexibility.

Short Answer

Golf is a physically demanding activity that requires strength and flexibility, comparable to traditional sports like baseball and soccer. To argue that golf is indeed a sport, one can emphasize its fitness benefits and athletic nature, suggesting that golfers are athletes who engage in significant physical effort.

Step-by-Step Solution

Step 1: Understand the Physical Demands of Golf

Recognize that golf requires a significant amount of physical effort, contrary to some beliefs. Players often engage in actions that demand both strength and flexibility, which can contribute to fitness levels. For example, golfing can burn over 700 calories during a typical nine-hole round, showcasing it as a physically demanding activity.

Step 2: Compare Golf with Traditional Sports

To strengthen the argument that golf is a sport, compare it to traditional sports like baseball and soccer. Highlight that players in these sports also need to demonstrate not just skill but also physical prowess. List some commonalities for these sports and golf, which include:

  • Requirement for physical fitness
  • Use of strength and stamina
  • Strategic thinking and skill development

Step 3: Formulate a Strong Claim

Create a revised claim that effectively counters the argument against golf as a sport. Emphasize its fitness benefits and athletic nature while taking into account the physical demands highlighted earlier. A proposed claim could be: ‚ÄöAuGolfing is a challenging form of exercise that involves significant physical effort, requiring both strength and skill, similar to conventional sports.‚ÄöAu This clearly positions golfers as athletes.

Related Concepts

Physical Demands

Defining the strength and flexibility required in activities like golf, showing it as a physically demanding sport

Caloric Burn

The amount of calories burned during physical activities, illustrating the physical exertion involved; over 700 calories for a nine-hole round of golf

Athletic Nature

The attributes of a sport that require physical fitness, skill, and strategic thinking, which are present in both golf and traditional sports like baseball and soccer.

Scroll to Top