Which revision eliminates the pronoun shift in the following sentences: …

Business Questions

Which revision eliminates the pronoun shift in the sentence below? if a student wishes to go on the field trip, they must bring in a permission slip. If a student wishes to go on the field trip, you must bring in a permission slip. If students wish to go on the field trip, he or she must bring in a permission slip. If students wish to go on the field trip, you must bring in your permission slips. If a student wishes to go on the field trip, he or she must bring in a permission slip?

Short Answer

The process for addressing pronoun shifts involves three steps: identifying the pronoun shift and its corresponding antecedents, selecting the correct form of the pronoun based on number and gender, and then revising the sentence for clarity with the corrected pronoun usage. This ensures the pronouns appropriately match their antecedents to avoid confusion.

Step-by-Step Solution

Step 1: Identify the Pronoun Shift

The first step in addressing the issue of pronoun shifts is to recognize where they occur in the sentence. A pronoun shift can confuse the reader when the pronouns do not agree with their corresponding antecedents. In this case, look for pronouns that mismatch in number or gender, leading to ambiguity.

Step 2: Choose the Correct Pronoun Form

Once you identify the pronoun shift, the next step is to select the appropriate pronoun form. This means ensuring that the pronoun matches its antecedent in both number (singular or plural) and gender (male or female). For example, using ‘he or she’ for a singular noun such as ‘student’ keeps the pronoun consistent.

Step 3: Revise the Sentence for Clarity

The final step is to revise the sentence by implementing the correct pronoun and structure. You can choose to maintain a singular pronoun with a singular antecedent or switch to a plural form if it fits the context. Examples to consider are:

  • ‘If a student wishes to go on the field trip, he or she must bring in a permission slip.’
  • ‘If students wish to go on the field trip, they must bring in their permission slips.’

Related Concepts

Pronoun Shift

A grammatical error occurring when the pronouns in a sentence do not agree with their corresponding antecedents in number or gender, leading to confusion.

Antecedent

A word, phrase, or clause that a pronoun refers to or replaces in order to avoid repetition.

Pronoun Form

The grammatical structure of a pronoun that indicates its relationship to the noun it replaces, including aspects such as number (singular or plural) and gender (male or female).

Scroll to Top