Compare the two claims above. How do they differ from …

English Questions

Compare the two claims above. How do they differ from one another? A. Claim 1 supports genetically modified foods, while Claim 2 opposes them. B. Claim 1 uses a formal academic style with complex syntax and advanced vocabulary. C. Claim 1 relies on anecdotal evidence, whereas Claim 2 uses diverse supporting evidence. D. Claim 1 adopts an informal style with contractions and personal point of view.

Short Answer

The evidence for genetically modified organisms (GMOs) differs between two claims: Claim 1 relies on anecdotal evidence and personal experiences, while Claim 2 is supported by over 2,000 scientific studies highlighting the safety and benefits of GMOs. This distinction indicates that Claim 2 offers a more credible and robust argument compared to the subjective nature of Claim 1.

Step-by-Step Solution

Step 1: Understand the Evidence Types

Claims about genetically modified organisms (GMOs) differ primarily in the type of evidence they use. Claim 1 leans on anecdotal evidence, relying on personal experiences and historical context, while Claim 2 utilizes extensive scientific studies. This distinction is crucial, as it reflects how each claim is constructed and supported.

Step 2: Analyze Claim 1

Claim 1 posits that genetic engineering has long been a part of agricultural practices, which suggests a positive view of GMOs. This claim emphasizes the historical consumption of genetically engineered foods based on experiential knowledge. However, it lacks the backing of scientific research, making it less formal and more subjective.

Step 3: Examine Claim 2

In contrast, Claim 2 asserts that over 2,000 scientific studies support the safety of GMOs and highlight their potential benefits. This claim stresses the role of GMOs in addressing global challenges like food insecurity and enhancing nutrition. By relying on empirical evidence, Claim 2 presents a more robust and credible argument compared to Claim 1.

Related Concepts

Evidence Types

Definitions of the different types of proof used to support claims, such as anecdotal evidence and scientific studies

Anecdotal Evidence

Personal experiences or narratives that serve as informal evidence for a claim, often lacking rigorous scientific support

Scientific Studies

Systematic investigations that use empirical methods to gather data and provide credible evidence, typically published in peer-reviewed journals.

Scroll to Top